1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

Questioning Gender Experience:

Discussion in 'Gender Identity and Expression' started by Verklighet, Jan 13, 2019.

  1. Verklighet

    Full Member

    Joined:
    Jun 13, 2018
    Messages:
    128
    Likes Received:
    26
    Location:
    Washington
    Gender:
    Female
    Gender Pronoun:
    She
    Sexual Orientation:
    Straight
    Out Status:
    Out to everyone
    Personally, I am a little ashamed to have shared this, but it has been bothering me.

    Maybe, a year and a half ago, I questioned my gender.
    I thought I could be a boy, so I switched up everything (even my name)
    behind the curtains of my family's house. Meaning, I did not share
    this with anyone, except my family. I felt great and they were very accepting.

    Next, maybe five months later, I realized, being a boy was not for me.
    I did not feel so good some time later and was very confused. I did not
    like being a boy, but I did not like being a girl. I continued to like
    boy's clothing and was easily comfortable posing as a guy online.

    I sometime found out thought a video that I was non-binary.

    I remember posting a comment there and people were commenting
    back about how happy they were for me. I remember writing about
    how angry I would get with myself when I tried thinking "are you a girl? boy?"
    and then realizing that I could be neither. I felt so good in that moment.

    Now, I don't know. As I type, "I must be a girl," I feel uneasy, but relief.
    I must be a girl.

    When I visited a water park with my family, a week ago, I had bought
    a swimsuit (rash guard and shorts) that could stop people from putting
    a gendered label on me too soon. Maybe my voice would give it away,
    but I probably was not going to be talking to them.. I put on a binder, underneath
    the rash guard and I felt so good. It was amazing, I remember. My brother
    told me while we were swimming, "this lady was looking at you and wondering,
    "girl or boy?"" and I did not mind. I was feeling great that day.

    The binder I was using was not waterproof, but it's still working okay.
    I was certain that I was going to buy a gc2b binder very soon, I just needed
    to get the courage to ask my mom (I was never very clear about how far
    I would want to take my non-binaryness, but that's okay).

    But now, I could care less. I don't need that binder now.
    I was wearing it yesterday and looking at my chest and thinking, "I am treating
    this as a bra. My chest looks feminine and I feel fine with it that way."
    I didn't see my
    chest as masculine even with the binder on. It looked like I had breasts and
    not a man's chest (the binder was not malfunctioning, it was working as it should).

    Above was a little hard to explain, but I hope you understand.



    The thing is, I think I feel weak as a girl.
    For a while, I have wanted to be taller so I could pass more androgynously, but not
    so much anymore. I was in the car today and I was imagining about
    taking a walk in this area with someone I used to know. I was a little annoyed
    with my presentation, like guess what, you are a girl and you know it, this is you and
    I just felt, stupid. Like, I should not be in love, walking with a person, that's
    every other girl's dream and it's silly, why are you in love? You are stereotypical...

    The same day, today, my younger sister shopped for herself and
    bought some clothes and showed them to me. She pulled out a sweater and
    I liked it. I had not allowed myself to like female clothing in a while.

    My mom bought me mostly female clothes, but men's pants and
    a boy's shirt and I have not even touched the girl's clothing.

    I feel stupid wanting to wear girl's clothing. I feel like long hair looks silly
    on me (I have short hair). I wouldn't want to wear makeup like my sister.
    I dont think I know how to accept myself as a girl, this is so hard.

    With my sexuality, I am bisexual (as you can read from my sub-profile).
    I liked the idea of being in a hetero (me as a female), but I wouldn't exactly
    mind being the man in a hetero relationship, me being the male for a woman.
    I wouldn't mind trying to be a woman's girlfriend, sometimes either. I would
    not want to be a man's boyfriend, though.

    I was never worried I could be a transtrender.
    I was never pushing my ideas on other people, I talked to one person
    a few times about my feelings and he supported me. I know you have
    to have dysphoria to be trans and for a while, I wanted my breasts
    gone and I wanted a male, muscular shape. I was watching that Buzzfeed video
    where they "trained like superheros" and the men were
    talking about gaining a "dorito shape" and I wanted that too.

    I feel so weird.
    I am sorry this is coming out in a tangent.


    Why did I go through this if I possibly end up identifying as my assigned birth sex?
     
  2. Verklighet

    Full Member

    Joined:
    Jun 13, 2018
    Messages:
    128
    Likes Received:
    26
    Location:
    Washington
    Gender:
    Female
    Gender Pronoun:
    She
    Sexual Orientation:
    Straight
    Out Status:
    Out to everyone
    I never shared these feelings with my family because
    I felt ashamed, as I do now.

    I almost had the courage to write my mom an email
    about it, but I chose not to.

    I would really appreciate some feedback on this,
    I only had the courage to talk to myself about this, until now.
    I also wanted to go on T at one point, to gain male-like muscles
    at one point, to get a deeper voice, but that did not happen.


    I read a book about a transgender girl and I remember
    the author wrote:

    When I thought of myself as a man, I could not see a future, nothing,
    but when I thought of myself as a woman, I could.

    I do not see a future of myself as a man, but maybe as a woman.
    Not entirely a woman, but I imagine myself smiling and laughing a lot.
    Just as me, not a man or a woman specifically.
    I don't know, feedback would be nice.
     
  3. Hawk

    Admin Team Full Member Away

    Joined:
    May 12, 2015
    Messages:
    13,419
    Likes Received:
    1,496
    Location:
    Alberta
    Gender:
    Male
    Gender Pronoun:
    He
    Sexual Orientation:
    Straight
    Out Status:
    Out to everyone
    Hey Verklighet, I had a lot of the same thoughts as you when I was questioning my gender. I thought I wanted top surgery, hormones, the works. It wasn't until I started working with people I didn't know, and seeing how they viewed and interacted with me, that I realized I'm more masculine-of-center than "male". For a long time, I was stuck in between labels, trans – butch – somewhere in-between. It wasn’t until I started talking to some older butch-identified people that I realized they had a lot of the same desires as myself.

    When it comes to presentation, you can choose to present yourself however you see fit; whatever makes you the most comfortable. Your presentation (expression) doesn’t change your gender identity. You can be a masculine female, feminine man, or a gender non-conforming Non-Binary person.

    Experimentation isn’t a bad thing. It’s nothing to be ashamed of, you now know what you do and don’t want, right? I think that’s great that you know that. People change their entire lives, and I don't think one person can say they were the same as they were X years ago.
     
  4. shasha1997

    Regular Member

    Joined:
    Dec 25, 2018
    Messages:
    47
    Likes Received:
    3
    Location:
    Taiwan
    Gender:
    Female
    Gender Pronoun:
    They
    Sexual Orientation:
    Bisexual
    Out Status:
    Out to everyone
    luckily i never had to suffer the pains you are going through as always considered myself feminine whether dating a man or a woman. when my husband proposed to me I made only one stipulation that I could date butch women after we were engaged. I promised fidelity to him with respect to no male affairs. I have always been lipstick in my relationships since ten years old. my first male partner was when I was sixteen. up till then i only had relations with butch lesbians.