Mass effect. Hands down. I'm such a massive nerd for that game, ive played all of them so many times and still feel like each character is having a unique experience.
If you had asked about two years ago I would have said WoW, but now I'm so over that I can't remember why I ever played. So The Sims 2 Pets wins. A game I have been playing since childhood; mine's pretty glitchy thanks to my obsessive cheating.
Dark Souls. So many different builds, armor sets, weapons, spells, etc. Also you can makr your character look ridiculous. I love it.
I haven't played much so Skyrim, but I tried to make She Hulk, with the ork, but I ended up with a Mohawk She Hulk.
Awww! Well, still though. SHE HULK! I think major props to the developers that they have marriage equality in the game.
I used to play City of Heroes, and I always felt it had one of the best character creation and customization options. Its hard to believe its been almost 10 years since I played.
If you ask me, I would say Continent of the Nine Seal <- they have some amazing character creation system... and Mass Effect too that my choices
Yeah, but, in the sims you get to kill them over and over again in many different ways, and the best thing is: It never gets old.